Putting Mahalo to the Test

Posted on in Blog

At the start of June, Jason Calcanis launched his newest project, Mahalo. The algorithm-free, human-guided search engine certainly represents a break from what we’ve come to expect in the industry. And, with four months under its belt, I figured it was time to put Mahalo to the test.

I know I’m a week late, but I also know that Radiohead’s new album is available for download. And, figuring that I can’t beat the price, I’d like to download it. Sadly, though, I can’t remember the album title.

So, a simple search at Mahalo.com – “radiohead”:


And it seems that the engine is reading my mind. The band name, big, blue, and bold, and, directly below it, a link to New Radiohead Album. Just what I’m looking for! So I click the link.

And, there it is, in the right corner, all the information I need, in a shaded “Guide Note” box. The record’s called In Rainbows, and I can’t wait to get my virtual hands on it. How do I now recall that it’s called In Rainbows? The simple guide note, of course, right at the top of my “New Radiohead Album” search:


You’ll notice, though, that Mahalo’s a little misleading here. Mahalo tells me that In Rainbows will be released beginning October 10. Thankfully, I know that happened a week ago, and this bit of mistaken tense doesn’t deter me.

Figuring that I just want the album already, I click on the title within the Guide Note. Sadly, still no download…just a new tracklisting:

This is good information, I guess, but ultimately gets me no closer to the record.

So, I shift my eyes back left. Suggestions to click on links for Radiohead – but that’s where I started – or In Rainbows Review – but I don’t want those. I just want the album already.

My eyes scroll down. Seven “recent” headlines, the earliest coming September 30. Nothing I’m looking for here.

So I look down further and, finally, I find a link to InRainbows.com and, finally, what I’m looking for.

The verdict on Mahalo: Pretty unsatisfying. In my mind, a quick-developing, semi-breaking entertainment story is where an engine such as Mahalo should thrive. But the engine essentially misled me through the process. In fact, had I just clicked on the band’s official site, right atop The Mahalo Top 7, I would have gotten the album. Instead, though, I followed the engine’s seemingly convenient lead, and was left in a lurch.

Mahalo for nothing, Jason.

Up Next

Sitemaps are dedicated files that organize and prioritize every piece of content on your website. Sitemapping helps search engines like Google and Bing make sense of your site’s pages and index the stuff that matters most. Once the lone purview of site administrators and professional SEOs, tools like Yoast, Google sitemaps and CMS platforms like...

Read More