Social Media: Are You a Maven or Wallflower?

Posted on in Blog

Marketing is no longer about just selling a product or service; it’s about developing a community around your brand and encouraging your customers to interact and join. This is why social media has become an essential marketing tool.

Social media KPIs are different for different businesses, but many focus on depth of engagement. Depth of engagement can be defined by the number of active social media channels and the level of engagement in each channel. Engagement includes actions like likes and shares, as well as regular initiation of discussion and participant/group feedback.

Recently, Charlene Li of Altimeter Group and Ben Elowitz, CEO of Wetpaint, released a study titled Engagement db. The report focused on the world’s top 100 brands and how well they are engaging consumers using social media. The key findings in the study revealed a significant correlation between deep social media engagement and financial performance. Those brands with deeper engagement at the right places performed better financially.

Dig into the study below to find out if you’re a social media maven, wallflower or something in between. And no matter where your business falls on this spectrum, know that Oneupweb offers flexible social media marketing services to improve your reach.

The Four Engagement Profiles of Social Media Brands

The report identifies four specific “engagement profiles” for each brand.

  • Mavens: These brands are engaged in seven or more channels and have an above-average engagement score. Brands like Starbucks and Dell are able to sustain a high level of engagement across multiple social media channels. Mavens not only have a robust strategy and dedicated teams focused on social media, but they also make it a core part of their go-to-market strategy. Companies like these could not imagine operating without a strong presence in social media.


  • Butterflies: These brands are engaged in seven or more channels but have lower-than-average engagement scores. Butterflies like American Express and Hyundai have initiatives in many different channels but tend to spread themselves too thin, investing in a few channels while letting others languish. Their ambition is to be a Maven and they may get there, but they still struggle with getting the full buy-in from their organizations to embrace the full multi-way conversation that deep engagement entails. If you think you’re in this category, consider scaling back the social platforms your business is active in so you can be really good at a few of them; then scale up again when you’re ready.
  • Selectives: These brands are engaged in six or fewer channels and have higher-than-average engagement scores. Selectives like H&M and Philips have a very strong presence in just a few channels where they focus on engaging customers deeply when and where it matters most. The social media initiatives at these brands tend to be lightly staffed (if they are at all), meaning, by default, they have to focus their efforts on just a few platforms and types of content.
  • Wallflowers: These brands are engaged in six or fewer channels and have below-average engagement scores. Wallflowers like McDonalds and BP are slow to, or are just getting started on, dipping their toes into social media waters. They are still trying to figure out social media by testing just a few channels. They are also cautious about the risks, uncertain about the benefits, and therefore engage only lightly in the channels where they are present.

Not Just For-Profit

Social media is currently one of the most creative communication channels out there. Participation should not be limited to for-profit businesses. According to The Columbus Dispatch, some central Ohio cities are trying out social media. So far, content includes festival photos and memos about road closings. A Gahanna resident actually used Twitter to report roadkill, which city officials promptly cleaned up.

Another example is the Puget Sound Blood Center in Seattle, Washington. The blood center’s online campaign launched earlier this summer has already generated 400 fans on Facebook and 1,200 followers on Twitter. Many of the PSBC donors explained that they would have never thought about giving blood unless they hadn’t been approached by the center on either Facebook or Twitter. When Type O supplies dropped during last month’s heat wave, blood center officials further relied on social media to find new donors. Those efforts paid off as the number of people interacting with the blood center doubled, with participants helping to get the word out about the shortage.

For us at Oneupweb, exploring the unique ways to leverage social media never gets old. While we’re in the early stages of social media strategy development, or when you’re stuck and not seeing good results, it’s important to ask yourself where your engagement level fits. Are you a Maven or are you a Wallflower?

If you’re looking for social media marketing support, you can count on our team’s creativity and decades of experience. Reach out to us online or call 231-922-9977.

Up Next

The private sector has invested substantially in lowering carbon emissions and creating lasting, impactful changes for how they do business. The focus on sustainability isn’t about marketing; it’s about doing the right thing. Still, brands need to communicate their eco-friendly accomplishments, policies and goals to accelerate industry-wide change and appeal to consumers who care –...

Read More